The short answer is…it depends on your needs and your budget.
There are a number of shed options that you can choose from if you are looking for a shed. You have plastic, wood, or metal. I am not going to compare all three types of sheds here. The goal of this article is to help you decide between metal and plastic sheds.
Each type has its pros and cons, and the right choice depends on your needs, budget, and preferences. Let’s break down the key differences between metal and plastic sheds to help you decide which is best for you.
Durability and Strength
Metal Sheds: Metal sheds are known for their strength and long-lasting durability. In Greenville, NC, the weather conditions can include heavy rain, wind, and even rare snow. As I am writing this, we are expecting a tropical storm..Yay!!
Metal sheds are built using galvanized steel or aluminum, making them highly resistant to these harsh elements. Metal sheds are tough and can easily handle wear and tear. This makes them ideal for long-term use in this area.
Plastic Sheds: Plastic sheds, often made from high-density polyethylene (HDPE) or vinyl, are also resistant to weather, but they may not be as sturdy as metal sheds when it comes to extreme conditions. In the hot, humid summers of Greenville, exposure to strong sunlight can cause fading or warping of plastic sheds. While they are generally durable, plastic sheds may not provide the same level of strength as metal in the face of severe weather.
If you are considering a plastic shed, make sure it is secured to the ground.
Verdict: If you need a shed that can withstand heavy-duty use and harsh weather typical of Greenville, metal sheds are the better choice. Plastic sheds are more suitable for moderate climates and lighter use. Metal Shed for the Win.
Maintenance Requirements
Metal Sheds: One downside of metal sheds is they can rust, especially in humid places like Greenville. You’ll need to do some upkeep to keep them from rusting or corroding. The good news is that many newer metal sheds have special coatings that help protect them, so they last longer and need less work. If you want to know more about how we keep our metal shed lasting longer, reach out to us.
Plastic Sheds: Plastic sheds are super easy to take care of. They don’t rust, rot, or need painting. In Greenville’s humid weather, that’s a big plus! Most of the time, you just need to spray them off with a hose to keep them clean and remove any pollen or green mold.
Verdict: If you want almost no maintenance, go with a plastic shed. Metal sheds need more attention, but if you take care of them, they can still last many years. For easy upkeep—plastic sheds win.
Aesthetic Appeal
Metal Sheds: Metal sheds have a more industrial look and feel, which not everyone loves. But you can still find them in different colors and designs that fit into many backyards. Some people like their sleek, strong look—especially if it matches other metal features on their property.
Plastic Sheds: Plastic sheds often look more modern and polished. Many have textures that look like wood or other natural materials. They also come in lots of colors, so it’s easy to match them to your home or garden. For Greenville homeowners who want something that looks nice and blends in well, plastic sheds might be the way to go.
Verdict: If looks are important for your property, plastic sheds usually offer more variety and style. Metal sheds are sturdy, but don’t always give you as many design choices. I will call this a tie.
Customization and Modifications
Metal Sheds: Metal sheds are easier to customize, especially if you want to add shelves or hooks inside. Their strong frames can handle extra storage, and they can be locked up more securely for added safety. You can see some examples of what our clients have done in our gallery.
Plastic Sheds:Plastic sheds aren’t as easy to change. Some come with built-in shelves or storage spots, but their lighter walls can’t hold heavy shelves or big changes like metal sheds can.
Verdict: If customizing and adding storage is important, metal sheds are the better choice. Plastic sheds are more limited in what they can handle. Metal sheds win.
Cost Considerations
Metal Sheds: Metal sheds usually cost less than plastic sheds, especially if you’re looking at the same size. They give you good value for your money, which is great if you need a bigger shed but want to stick to a budget.
Plastic Sheds: Plastic sheds cost more because of the materials and how they’re made. But they also come with perks like low maintenance and a nice variety of styles, which can make the higher price worth it for some people.
Verdict: If saving money is your top priority, metal sheds are usually the better deal. But if you’re willing to pay extra for convenience and style, a plastic shed might be worth it. Metal shed wins
Environmental Impact
Metal Sheds: Metal sheds are often made from recyclable materials, and they can be recycled at the end of their lifespan, making them a more environmentally friendly choice. However, metal production can have a high carbon footprint.
Plastic Sheds: Plastic sheds are typically made from synthetic materials, which are not biodegradable. While some plastic sheds are made from recyclable materials, the production process for plastic can be less eco-friendly compared to metal.
Verdict: Metal sheds are generally more environmentally friendly, especially if you consider recyclability. Plastic sheds have a larger environmental impact due to their synthetic materials. Metal shed wins.
Conclusion
So, are metal sheds better than plastic sheds? It depends on what you value most. If you need a strong, cost-effective shed that can withstand tough weather, a metal shed is likely your best option. However, if you prefer a shed that looks polished, requires little maintenance, and fits well in a garden, a plastic shed may be the way to go.
Consider your budget and how much maintenance you’re willing to do before making your decision. Both metal and plastic sheds have their advantages, so the right choice ultimately comes down to your specific needs.
If you’re still unsure about which type of shed is right for you, contact us today! We can help you make a decision that suits you.
Comparison Summary Table
| Feature | Metal Sheds | Plastic Sheds |
| Durability | High durability, withstands weather | Durable, but may warp in sun |
| Maintenance | Requires rust prevention | Very low maintenance |
| Aesthetic Appeal | Industrial, limited styles | Modern, wood-like textures |
| Customization | Easy to add shelves/hooks | Limited modification options |
| Cost | Generally more affordable | More expensive, but low upkeep |
| Environmental Impact | Recyclable, but high carbon footprint | Synthetic, less eco-friendly |